What every person needs to survive in a rapidly changing world, foundation for critical. Learning to negotiate and improve these skills can aid us in becoming better thinkers, communicators, and creators. But do we really understand what critical thinking is and how to improve our skillset. One of them emphasizes physical bodies and environments. It is a critical thinking supplement to any textbook or course.
Download now this book is designed for students to use independently to enhance their critical thinking skills. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis this volume provides a framework improving how analysts thinkand, by extension, how policymakers act. Critical thinking presupposes knowledge of the most basic structures in thinking the elements of thought and the most basic intellectual standards for thinking universal intellectual standards. Common thinking flaws usually involve the use of system 1 thinking. Critical thinking critical thinking recognizes the ways in which our minds often mislead us and seeks to correct those thinking flaws. The pacific northwest national laboratory pnnl has for some time been involved in both the development of software tools meant to aid in intelligence analysis ia. The main goal of tiacritis and the associated textbook is to help the intelligence analysts understand this complexity and be able to cope with it. Description of the book critical thinking for strategic intelligence. Critical thinking provides such a framework and goes further.
Without critical think ing, current beliefs and methods are not ques tioned, as long as they appear to produce results that can be reasonably explained. The subject is complex, and several different definitions exist, which generally include the rational, skeptical, unbiased analysis, or evaluation of. To be most effective, analysts need an overarching, reflective framework to add structured reasoning to sound, intuitive thinking. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis second edition. Dick heuers contribution to intelligence analysis by jack davis i applaud cias center for the study of intelligence for making the work of richards j. The effective story is about people who have lived a knowledge181 sharing idea and how things happen in a reallife situation. The road to critical thinking and intelligence analysis. Download pdf from critical thinking to argument free. The triarchic test of intellectual skills is psychologically derived, but does not try to separate critical thinking from intelligence. Degree in law enforcement intelligence and analysis cj 839 has been approved by michigan state university as of january 1, 2009. Psychology of intelligence analysis central intelligence agency. Properly distinguishes between underlying intelligence and analysts assumptions and judgments incorporates alternative analysis where appropriate demonstrates relevance to u.
Mar 01, 2007 great book on insights into how intelligence analysts go about problems, their bias and what needs to be done to create a effective analysis. Handson thinking skills ebook the critical thinking. Critical thinking is thinking that drills down to the essence of a problem. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis 2nd printing. Jan, 2019 analytical thinking skills are an invaluable asset to have. Create an intelligence analyst professional development program spanning multiple air force specialty codes. It asserts that people who are skilled critical thinkers.
You can empower yourself for the triumphs of tomorrow, but only if you. Critical thinking has been defined as reasonable, reflective thinking that is focused on what to believe or do. Critical thinking in intelligence analysis researchgate. Intelligence analysts face complex and dynamic problems. The pacific northwest national laboratory pnnl has for some time been involved in both the development of software tools meant to aid in intelligence analysis ia, and in actually performing intelligence analysis as part of the department of energys field intelligence element fie. Criticalthinkingandintelligenceanalysis2007 identifierark ark.
Critical thinking and intelligence analysis second edition moore, david t. The watsonglaser critical thinking appraisal, the cornell critical thinking test, and the new jersey test of reasoning skills are derived from the philosophical tradition. Preparing for the future of air force intelligence analysis. It contains advice and examples of students writing to illustrate poor performance and demonstrate how to produce effective critical discourse. Whether performed by national agencies or local law enforcement, the ultimate objective of intelligence analysis is to develop timely inferences that can be acted. Critical thinking is key to the analysis conducted to better understand situations. Great book on insights into how intelligence analysts go about problems, their bias and what needs to be done to create a effective analysis.
Harris published 2012 whether performed by national agencies or local law enforcement, the ultimate objective of intelligence analysis is to develop. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis second edition david t. Handson thinking skills ebook the critical thinking co. Proposed curriculum for analytical thinking what i have in mind as a complete workshop consists of the following nine topics. The psychology of intelligence analysis national academies. Cognitive science and intelligence analysis summary 1 recommendations 3 preface 4 introduction 4 i. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis national. Accomplished instructors and intelligence practitioners beebe and pherson have created a set of twelve robust, classtested cases on events in foreign intelligence, counterintelligence, terrorism, homeland security, law enforcement, and decisionmaking support. Visual analytics for sensemaking in criminal intelligence analysis valcri project. It also describes future challenges for air force intelligence analysis. Although technological marvels assist analysts by cataloging and presenting data, information, and evidence in new ways, they do not do analysis.
The course can also be applied to the certificate in law enforcement. Intelligence analysts critical thinking skills, is a webbased system with case studies and knowledge. The final paper 812 typed, doublespaced pages will either 1 argue for the intelligence or lackthereof of some entity e. Teaching intelligence analysis with tiacritis tecuci g. This paper defines critical thinking in the context of intelligence analysis, explains how it influences the entireintelligence process, explores how it toughens the art of intelligence analysis, suggests how it. A course study in analytical thinking perceptual edge. Critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis 2 figure 2 also shows how the processing engine s interact with enviro nmental and individual factors. Whereas earlier analysis of cognitive functioning from a psychological perspective had focused on notions of fixed intelligence, the new cognitive psychology of the 1970s introduced a more dynamic. This paper defines critical thinking in the context of intelligence analysis, explains how it influences the entire intelligence process, explores how it toughens the art of intelligence analysis, suggests how it may be taught, and deduces how analysts can be persuaded to adopt this habit. Critical thinking comprises the mental processes, strategies, and representations people use to solve problems, make decisions, and learn new concepts. This pdf is being distributed exclusively to participants of the 39th annual international conference on critical thinking for use during the conference to enhance their learning. Pdf 10 critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis semantic.
Critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis, ergonomics a systems approach, isabel l. It also identifies, describes and offers practical guidance to the development of training for the skills required for critical thinking in intelligence analysis. Critical thinking is a collection of cognitive skills that allow us to. Criticalthinking and intelligenceanalysis 2007 identifierark ark. Also, in practice, judgmental thinking usually involves a lot of logical fallacies. The key to increasing your critical thinking abilities and improving your analytical skills lies in your desire to succeed. Critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis this chapter by douglas h. In an environment characterized by an everincreasing flow of data and resulting complexity, the. A guide for practitioners, charles has produced a book aimed at the practical level and designed to empower the intelligence analyst with concepts and tools to achieve a tangible result. Proposals to improve intelligence analysis have had little impact as analysts, their. Critical competencies for 35f analysts include general mental ability, critical thinking skills, problemsolving skills, domain knowledge, communication skills, adaptability, openmindedness, and. This paper defines critical thinking in the context of intelligence analysis, explains how it influences the entire intelligence process, explores how it toughens the art of intelligence analysis. Critical thinking for strategic intelligence, second edition produced by the berkeley electronic. The first is due to richard paul who gave a definition of critical thinking which.
Pdf critical thinking and intelligence analysis5 pablo pablo. In an environment characterized by an everincreasing flow of data and resulting complexity, the development of intelligence analysis is of core importance. Analysts form judgements and make decisions based on limited available information, while dealing with inherent. A guide for practitioners, charles has produced a book aimed at the practical level and designed to empower the intelligence analyst with concepts and tools. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis second.
Assessing competencies and proficiency of army intelligence. Handson thinking skills develops spatial, verbal, motor, visual, and analytical thinking skills necessary for success in reading, writing, math, and science. They easily transfer and apply across many spectrums of our lives. Good thinking skills are really not all that complicated, but you need a bit of knowledge and continuing practice to turn the learned skills into instinctive habits. Critical thinking is an illdefined concept in the cognitive sciences, so this question most likely has as many answers as there are measures of iq and critical thinking. Download cognitive bias and critical thinking in open source. I consider myself a person with reasonable intelligence. Critical thinking and intelligence analysis by david t. We will try to make sense of all this using skills of critical thinking. A range of established tests and surveys can be used to assess competencies and proficiency of 35f analysts. The essence of critical thinking concepts and tools distilled into a 20page pocketsize guide.
Critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis intechopen. The model can, and has been, used to make testable predictions about the factors that influence critical thinking and about the associated consequences. The skills addressed by this series include deductive thinking, handeye coordination, spatial awareness, symmetry, classifying, visual perception, and more. Resources for successful teaching, learning magazine my little artist loves to color, but traditional coloring books dont keep her attention. Critical thinking is the analysis of facts to form a judgment. Whats somewhat hard to read and understand at times and i would have values more examples of intelligence that demonstrates bias or critical thinking the book focused only on cuban missile.
Download book from critical thinking to argument in pdf format. Critical thinking should not be thought of as an effort to refute any particular choice or decision, but rather as a way to balance evidence, reason, and options. Read online cognitive bias and critical thinking in open source. Top ten needs for intelligence analysis tool development. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. Accomplished instructors and intelligence practitioners beebe and pherson have created a set of twelve robust, classtested cases. Critical competencies for 35f analysts include general mental ability, critical thinking skills, problemsolving skills, domain knowledge, communication skills, adaptability, openmindedness, and conscientiousness.
Though often confused with intelligence, critical thinking is not intelligence. Analysts form judgements and make decisions based on limited available information, while dealing with inherent uncertainty, knowing that the assessments they make provide the basis for significant decisions and actions. Students have fun building manipulative relationships on each activity page using attribute. The tools they use are logic, research, and experience. This is a ed file and may not be redistributed to others in any way, including in printed or digital format. Critical thinking for strategic intelligence, second edition. Critical thinking skills for intelligence analysis.
Critical thinking for strategic intelligence, second. We divided the twenty questions into four groups, focusing on the four stages of generating an analytic product. It makes recommendations related to doctrine, training and career field development, analysis tools, and processes that can help to address the lessons from the past and prepare air force intelligence analysts for the challenges of the future. Your brain will naturally try to fit disparate pieces of data.
Critical thinking for strategic intelligence, washington, dc. Critical thinking for strategic analysis is organized around twenty key questions that all analysts should ask as they prepare to conduct research, draft papers, and present their analysis. It is best used in conjunction with the analytic thinking guide. Edition 2 ebook written by katherine hibbs pherson, randolph h. I am good at think laterally, but sometimes i feel i missed important critical evaluations of a simple problem. Post an explanation of the importance of critical thinking and the implications of. Here comes an account of a variety of problems that may so easily be overlooked in discussions of the task of connecting the dots in situations as complex as intelligence. The course can also be applied to the certificate in law enforcement intelligence offered by the school of criminal justice. Although technological marvels assist analysts by cataloging and presenting data. Because this book is now out of print, this portable document file pdf is formatted. It is introspective thinking that questions everything and everyone.
966 164 955 289 291 446 840 1411 251 1113 693 1255 1101 179 1345 753 988 173 482 218 1071 58 1107 97 549 252 94 734 751 1344 555 192 60 214 59 607 45 845 1181 606 80 773